Goalies the HABS may look at this off-season
Written by Fred Arshoff
Edited by Judy Pitcher
I’d like to thank my editor Judy Pitcher for her excellent editing of my article. A tip of my hat to you, Judy.
I decided to write this article, as my friend Karen Elizabeth Knechtel asked, “Will the HABS draft a goaltender in this year’s draft?” As I always do, I’ll answer in the form of an article so everyone knows my thoughts.
As most of us know that the HABS drafted Carey Price in the 2005 NHL Entry draft at 5th overall and developed him into a true #1 goaltender. Since then they have not drafted, traded or signed a goalie who has turned into a #1 goaltender, who could truly be the replacement for Carey Price.
None of the goalies drafted by former GM Marc Bergevin have panned out.
Zackary Fucale was drafted from the 2013 NHL Entry draft in the 2nd round at 36th overall. In the 2021-22 season Fucale played 4 games with the Washington Capitals and that seems to be the extent of his NHL career.
The last goalie drafted by the HABS who has played in the NHL is Cayden Primeau. Primeau was drafted in the 2017 NHL Entry draft in the 7th round as the 99th overall selection. Although, still with the HABS organization, I don’t see him as the #1 goaltender but as a back-up at best.
There was Charlie Lindgren who was signed as a free-agent in 2015, he has played 110 NHL games and is currently with the Washington Capitals.
The HABS traded picks to the St Louis Blues to get Jake Allen to be the back-up for Carey Price.
The HABS then picked up Samuel Montembeault off waivers from the Florida Panthers to be Jake Allen’s back-up, once it was confirmed that Carey Price could no longer play due to injury. Although, Monty has become the HABS #1 goaltender, in my eyes he is not a true #1 goalie.
I have no clue if this was bad scouting or poor development, but it was under GM Marc Bergevin and the previous management group. Hopefully, under the current GM Kent Hughes things will change.
The HABS drafted Jacob Fowler in the 2023 NHL Entry draft from the 3rd round at 69th overall. . By all accounts he is considered a Blue Chip prospect, however we won’t see him with the HABS organization this coming season as he has chosen to return to Boston College in the NCAA for the upcoming 2024-25 season. Although, Fowler is considered a Blue Chip prospect, so was Charlie Lindgren when he was at St Clouds in the NCAA and unfortunately did not live up to expectations
I always believe in having a plan B and that would be to draft Carter George in the second round, if he is still available. The 2nd round pick was acquired from the Colorado Avalanche, along with Justin Barron, in the Artturi Lehkonen trade. The HABS don’t have their own 2nd round pick in this draft, as it was traded to the Arizona Coyotes to acquire Christian Dvorak.
Carter George played for Canada at the U18 WJC and was outstanding. Carter George’s numbers at the U18 WJC: 6GP 2.33GAA 0.915SV% OHL Owen Sound Attack: 56GP 3.30GAA 0.907SV% I was very impressed with Carter George at the U18 WJC and feel with proper development he has the potential to become a #1 goalie in the NHL. He is currently the 2nd best goalie on the North American scouting list.
For a plan C and to have a back-up goalie for the Laval Rocket, I would invite Mathis Rousseau to the HABS development camp is held soon after the NHL Entry draft. Let’s see what he brings to the table as he went undrafted in the 2023 NHL Entry draft. Mathis Rousseau was the starting goalie for Team Canada at the 2024 WJC. He is the 1st starting goalie for Team Canada to go undrafted twice in the NHL draft. To invite him to development camp doesn’t use up a draft pick or salary cap space. If he look promising, he can be signed to an AHL contract for Laval. There is still plenty of room to do that, as the HABS have 58/90 players allowed on their reserve list.
SOURCES
ZACHARY FUCALE STATS
https://www.capfriendly.com/players/zachary-fucale
CAYDEN PRIMEAU STATS
https://www.capfriendly.com/players/cayden-primeau ‘
CHARLIE LINDGREN STATS
https://www.capfriendly.com/players/charlie-lindgren#:~:text=Charlie%20Lindgren’s%20salary%20is%20%241%2C000,a%20value%20of%20%248%2C850%2C000.
JAKE ALLEN STATS
https://www.capfriendly.com/players/jake-allen
SAMUEL MONTEMBEAULT STATS
https://www.capfriendly.com/players/samuel-montembeault
CARTER GEORGE STATS
https://www.capfriendly.com/players/carter-george
JUDY’S THOUGHTS
What seems lost in this conversation are all the goalies already in the HABS organization, including 3 of the 9 draft picks from the 2023 NHL Entry draft.
Here are goaltenders in the system or draft prospects from previous drafts.
JAKUB DOBES 2020 NHL Entry draft 5th round at 136th overall. He is 6’4″ 201lbs 23 years old. 2023-24 Laval Rocket 52 GP 2.03GAA 0.901SV%
STRAUSS MANN undrafted 6’0″ 174lbs 25 years old 2023-24 Laval Rocket 15GP 3.69GAA 0,879SV% 2023-24 Trois Riviers 11GP 2.59GAA 0,910SV%
2023 NHL ENTRY DRAFT PICKS: JACOB FOWLER 3rd round 69th 6’2″ 214lbs 19 years old 2023-24 NCAA Boston College 39GP 2.14GAA 0.926SV%
QUENTIN MILLER 4th round 128th 6’3″ 187lbs 19 years old 2023-24 Remparts 27GP 3.04GAA 0,905SV% 2023-24 Oceanic 15GP 2.60GAA 0.917SV% 2022-23 Quentin Miller was the back-up to William Rousseau under coach Patrick Roy when the Quebec Remparts won the Memorial Cup.
YEVGENI VOLOKHIN 5th round 144th 6’3″ 168lbs 19 years old
2023-24 Mamonty Yugry/MHL 31GP 1.57GAA 0.938SV%
Tuesday the HABS signed Swiss goalie Connor Hughes as back-up to Dobes for the Rocket. He is 6’4″ 225lbs 27 years old. His stats 2023-24 Lausanne HC 19GP 1.73GAA 0.940SV%