Players Complaining About Player Development With Montreal Canadiens
Written by Fred Arshoff
I’d like to thank Marlene Wall, very much, for the merging of the four photos into one to make the cover photo for this article.
The main reason I am writing this article is Bobby Boutilier said Jesperi Kotkaniemi was correct and did the right thing. I admit I added several other players, or their family members as well, who have called out the Montreal Canadiens. I prefer to do it all in one article than each player individually
The following former Habs players, or in their organization, have called out the Canadiens this season: Kotkaniemi, McNiven, Frolik, and now Fucale.
I will go into detail about them all with the exception of Frolik. You can read my thoughts on him at https://montrealsportsblog.wordpress.com/2021/11/08/michael-frolik-speaking-out/
Jesperi Kotkaniemi
I won’t say anything bad about him taking the contract that the Carolina Hurricanes offered him. I’m sure we all would take as much salary, as we could, and if someone would want to overpay us we wouldn’t complain at all. What I do have a major problem is calling out the Canadiens about his development. In the 2020-21 season he had the same coaches as Nick Suzuki and Jake Evans, after he was called up, and we can see how well they have developed. I will admit by making the trade, to obtain Eric Staal, did take away ice time. And not being dressed for all games but every General Manager will make moves they feel will improve their team and hopefully bring them the Stanley Cup.
Perhaps if the Habs allowed KK to play a full season with the Laval Rocket, instead of with the big club, his development may have been better. I believe he had an OPT OUT clause, in his contract, so if he was sent to the Rocket he could have opted out of his contract and gone back to Finland to play for his father’s team. None of us will ever know, with any certainty, if he would have used his OPT OUT CLAUSE if sent to Laval.
Being a first round draft choice, third overall player selected in the NHL Entry draft in 2018, doesn’t bring an automatic guarantee you will be playing every day. Just as the coaching staff has to help you develop, the player has to also do their part. If that means hiring a personal trainer to work with you, during the off season, on the elements of your game that need improvement do it. One has to invest in themselves.
In the 2019-20 season when they saw how he was playing they did try to help him by sending him to the Rocket, then coached by Joel Bouchard who worked very well with young hockey players to get them NHL ready. As an example of Bouchard’s coaching Jake Evans, who was a 7th round draft choice, is now a regular with the Canadiens. When KK suffered a spleen injury, while playing for the Rocket by a dirty hit, the Habs got him the best medical help they could. They never rushed him to come back, but told him to let the injury heal properly.
He has 1 pt in his last 9 games and had a season low TOI of 9:51 last night vs. St. Louis as of November 14, 2021. He is on the same team as friend Sebastian Aho and both are fellow countrymen from Finland. In 13 games KK has 2 goals and one assist. These numbers show it’s not the Canadiens development that failed him so maybe he should look inward.
Zack Fucale
In this case it actually wasn’t him that called out the Canadiens, but his father, so I can’t put full blame on Zack. What I will say is family members, girlfriends etc of professional athletes shouldn’t be calling out teams at all. All the other teams hear that and it will make it harder for the athlete to find employment as no team wants to be called out. As case in point, of this, is Greg Pateryn whose wife called out the Habs in the 2016-17 season. Since then he has played for four different organizations.
Fucale was drafted by the Canadiens in the 2013 NHL Entry draft. He was the 36th overall player chosen, in that draft, in the second round. He started playing in the Habs organization, in the 2015-16 season, bouncing around between the AHL and ECHL until the end of the 2017-18 season. They did a lot to try and get Zack playing time and help him get his confidence back by loaning him, in the 2017-18 and 2018-19 season, to Team Canada of the Spengler Cup. The Goalie Coach of the St. Johns Ice Caps was Vincent Riendeau who since then is now a Goalie and Russia Scout for the Canadiens. At the same time he was also Assistant General Manager of the St. Johns Ice Caps. Due to that perhaps he didn’t have enough time to work one on one with Zack but I’m sure one of the team’s other coaches worked with him.
When the Las Vegas Golden Knights signed him, in their first season, Fucale didn’t make their AHL team and was sent to their ECHL team.
In the 2020-21 season Zack signed with the Washington Capitals.
To date all of his contracts have been two way contracts.
Perhaps if he too invested in himself, by hiring a personal trainer to work with him one on one during the off season, he would be better. True it costs money but if you’re better you will get paid more and have a longer career.
Michael McNiven
Of all the players, or family members, that have called out the Canadiens, this season, the only one still with the organization is McNiven.
He was undrafted and signed by the Habs, for the 2015-16 season, and at the time won the Award as Goalie Of The Year in the OHL (Ontario Hockey League).
One of the biggest problems he faced, when he signed with the Canadiens, was they had also just signed Charlie Lindgren who they thought more highly of thus worked to try and get him NHL ready faster. Then they drafted Cayden Primeau who they considered the best of the three.
Due to that McNiven has been sent, more often than not, to ECHL teams. I can understand his frustration as with each different team is a different Goalie Coach and they may have a different way they want you to play.
As an example of how much he has been bounced around in the ECHL, by the Canadiens, in the 2019-20 season he was sent to three ECHL teams to get playing time.
McNiven actually when they were in the bubble, before being approached by the Canadiens, went to work out with the forwards who started to practice to show good faith.
There isn’t very much Michael can really do as at the end of this season he will still be an RFA thus can’t sign with another team unless they give him an offer sheet and then hope the Habs don’t match it.
McNiven is one player I’d like to see get a fair chance, of playing for the Habs or another NHL team, as he has done everything asked of him but hasn’t been given a fair chance. There are other goalies they’ve thought more highly of.